Delightful Mini Cheesecake Jars

These bite-sized sweetened condensed milk cheesecakes deliver a heavenly mix of creaminess in handy individual portions. The smooth, luscious filling sitting on a crumbly graham base makes for a dessert you can't resist - fancy yet homey. Using sweetened condensed milk instead of regular sugar gives these little treats an extra silky feel that makes them stand out from your average cheesecake. I whipped these up for my kid's graduation celebration just days ago. Everyone loved getting their own little dessert, and many folks wanted to know how I made them. The trick? Sweetened condensed milk creates this incredible smoothness you just can't get from plain sugar.

Key Ingredients

• Cream Cheese: Go for the full-fat kind at room temp. I've found cold cream cheese creates bumps, and low-fat versions just don't work right
• Sweetened Condensed Milk: This wonder ingredient brings sweetness and creaminess together. Stick with full-fat for the best outcome
• Graham Crackers: Use fresh, crunchy ones for your base. Honey grahams add a nice sweet touch
• Eggs: They need to be room temperature for smooth mixing. Cold eggs might make your batter split
• Extracts: Vanilla and lemon together make magic. Real extracts taste way better than imitations

Through my many years of cheesecake baking, I've learned ingredient temperature really matters. When everything's at room temp, it all blends together better and gives you that dreamy smooth texture we're going for.

Simple Cooking Instructions

1. Base Building

• Smash graham crackers until they're fine and even
• Stir in melted butter till it looks like damp sand
• Put exactly one tablespoon in each jar for even crusts
• Push down lightly with a spoon, but don't pack too tight

2. Mix Creation

• Whip cream cheese by itself until smooth, around 3 minutes
• Clean your bowl and beaters well between adding stuff
• Add condensed milk in a slow stream while mixing
• Drop in eggs one by one, mixing just enough to blend
• Stir in extracts carefully to keep everything smooth

3. Berry Topping

• Cut stems off fresh strawberries, cutting big ones in half
• Mix with sugar, cornstarch, water, and lemon juice in your pot
• Warm slowly while stirring so it stays smooth
• Smoosh berries a bit as they cook for good texture
• Cook until sauce thickens and sticks to your spoon, about 5-8 minutes

4. Putting It Together

• Fill each jar using the same scoop for even amounts
• Don't fill to the top - leave room for sauce and toppings
• Tap jars softly to get air bubbles out
• Wipe jar edges clean with a wet paper towel before baking

5. Oven Time

• Set jars on a baking sheet with sides for safety
• Pour hot water into the pan halfway up the jars
• Bake at 300°F - getting this temperature right matters
• They're done when centers still wobble slightly

Pin it

My grandma always showed me to tap each jar before baking to get rid of bubbles. She'd say patience makes perfect cheesecake, and after making these tons of times, I totally get what she meant.

Pin it

Cheesecake Making Secrets

Getting that perfect texture means knowing how things work together. The sweetened condensed milk does double duty for sweetness and structure, while careful mixing keeps everything silky smooth.

Keeping and Eating

These little treats stay good in the fridge for up to five days. Their personal size makes them great for parties since everyone can just grab their own without any fuss.

Pin it

Warm Ingredients Work Better

Using room temperature stuff isn't just a random tip. It's really important for stopping lumps and making sure everything bakes evenly. I learned this when I rushed once and used cold cream cheese. Ended up with little lumps all through my cheesecake.

Smart Cooking Tricks

• Check if they're done by giving the pan a little shake. Centers should wiggle a bit
• Let them cool all the way before adding toppings or you'll get water droplets
• When storing, don't tighten lids completely to keep moisture away

I've tweaked this recipe for years and found these mini treats bring the same happiness as big cheesecakes but they're way easier to handle and super cute. The single servings are perfect for gatherings, and you can top them with anything you want. They're fancy enough for special occasions but simple enough for a random Tuesday night sweet tooth.

Pin it

Last Words

These tiny sweetened condensed milk cheesecakes show what's great about home cooking. They're easy but still fancy, classic but with a fresh twist, and so fun to share. After making batch after batch in my kitchen, I've realized their magic isn't just in how creamy they are or their perfect size, but in how they bring folks together. Each little jar shows the care that went into making it. What started as an answer to serving problems has turned into one of my favorite recipes. The mix of that rich, smooth filling with the buttery graham cracker bottom, topped with bright strawberry sauce, makes a dessert that feels both old-fashioned and new. The recipe isn't complicated, but it's the small things that matter. Room temp ingredients, gentle mixing, and the right oven temperature turn these mini cheesecakes from just okay to amazing.

Frequently Asked Questions

→ Can I make these ahead?

Absolutely, you can fix them up to 2 days before and keep in the fridge. Just add the topping right before you serve them.

→ What size jars should I use?

Go for 4-ounce mason jars to get the ideal single-serving size.

→ Why mix on low with eggs?

Mixing slowly stops too much air getting in that can make your cheesecakes crack.

→ Can I use different toppings?

For sure, try other fruit toppings or even some caramel instead.

→ How long do these keep?

They'll stay good in your fridge for up to 5 days, or you can freeze them without the topping for up to 3 months.