Pin it
I whipped up these Tiny Crème Brûlée Cheesecakes for my sister's get-together and now the whole gang's asking how to make them. They pack all the good stuff from smooth cheesecake with that satisfying brittle sugar crust you get from crème brûlée. What's cool? They're actually not that hard to throw together but they look totally impressive. There's nothing like breaking through that caramelized sugar shell into the velvety cheesecake waiting underneath—it's absolutely divine.
Delightful Dessert Mashup
These cute little treats deliver double the goodness. You'll enjoy that smooth rich cheesecake inside plus the thrill of smashing through a crisp sugar top. They're perfect for gatherings since everyone gets their own personal portion—no need to slice or pass around. And you can fix them up beforehand, which really comes in handy when you've got company coming.
Shopping List
- For the Base: You'll need some graham crackers for crushing, butter, and a little sugar—simple stuff from your pantry.
- For the Middle: Get cream cheese that's really soft, eggs, vanilla, and just a tiny bit of heavy cream to make everything extra smooth.
- For the Topping: Just plain sugar—we'll turn it into something amazing.
Pin it
Cooking Steps
- Get your foundation ready:
- Warm your oven to 325°F. Combine graham crumbs with melted butter and sugar until it looks like damp sand. Push it down into muffin tins—the bottom of a spoon works great for this. Bake them quickly for about 5 minutes.
- Create your cheesecake mixture:
- Whip cream cheese and sugar together until completely smooth. Drop in eggs one by one, then stir in vanilla and cream until the mixture looks just right.
- Add your mixture:
- Pour this creamy mix over your warm crusts, filling about three-quarters way up. They'll expand slightly during baking. Stick them in for roughly 20 minutes—they should still jiggle a bit.
- The exciting finish:
- After they've totally cooled down, dust sugar on top then grab your torch. Watch as the sugar bubbles and turns into a gorgeous amber color—it's so satisfying.
Pin it
Insider Baking Tips
Let me share what I've figured out after making these tons of times. Your ingredients must be at room temp or you'll end up with bumpy filling—and nobody wants that. The torch isn't just fancy equipment, it really gives you that perfect crackling top. If you're using your oven's broiler instead, don't take your eyes off them—they burn super fast. I sometimes throw a dash of cinnamon into the crust—it makes everything taste so comforting.
Presentation Ideas
These cuties stand out by themselves but adding some fresh berries alongside really makes them pop. When I have friends over, I'll pair them with tiny espresso cups—feels so classy. Sometimes I'll sprinkle the plates with powdered sugar or cocoa, add a little mint leaf, and suddenly my kitchen feels like a fancy restaurant. They're great for dinner parties because everyone gets their own individual dessert.
Storage Tips
These mini cheesecakes stay good in the fridge for about 3 days if you put them in something airtight. The sugar top will soften in there, but don't worry—just add more sugar and torch it again right before serving. I love making these ahead when company's coming—one less thing to stress about on the day. Just leave that caramel topping for the last minute since that crack when breaking through should be fresh.
Fun Variations
I sometimes swap graham crackers for chocolate wafers in the crust—it completely changes the game. Try putting a bit of raspberry sauce between the bottom and filling—it looks stunning and tastes incredible. My sister goes crazy when I use almond extract instead of vanilla—gives them this special bakery flavor. The last batch I made had a tiny sprinkle of sea salt on the caramel top—everyone couldn't get enough of that sweet-salty mix.
Pin it
Elegant Touches
Want to go all out? Try making them in small tart pans—totally transforms their appearance. During Christmas I'll top them with sugar-coated cranberries or edible flowers—makes them look straight from a fancy bakery. That's what I enjoy about this dessert—you can keep it simple or dress it up. I try something different each time I make them, but that perfect blend of creamy cheesecake and crackling top is always a winner.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Can I skip using a torch?
A torch works best, but a broiler does the trick too. Just keep an eye on it and turn the tray for even caramelization.
- → How early can I prep these?
Make the cheesecakes up to 48 hours ahead. Add and caramelize the sugar topping right before serving for that perfect crunch.
- → Why are there cracks in mine?
Cracks come from overbaking or mixing too long. Stop mixing when just combined and bake until the centers are still a little wobbly.
- → Can these be frozen?
Yes! Freeze them plain (no caramel topping) for up to three months. Thaw overnight and brûlée before serving.
- → Which sugar works best for caramelizing?
Regular white sugar is ideal. Spread it evenly for that golden crackle on top.
Conclusion
Creamy Mini Cheesecake Cups are a delightful mash-up of two fan-favorites. The smooth cheesecake filling and crunchy caramelized tops make these portioned desserts a hit at any gathering.