Pin it
Take a bite of these rich brownies that blend all the beloved tastes of traditional banana pudding. These Banana Pudding Brownies mix the gooey goodness of a classic brownie with smooth, homemade vanilla pudding, fresh bananas, and those iconic vanilla wafer cookies. Whenever I whip these up, my home fills with sweet vanilla scents and caramelized banana aromas, taking me back to sunny days enjoying banana pudding at my nana's place.
I took these to our family potluck last Sunday, and even my nephew's picky kids who normally turn down anything fruity couldn't stop eating them. What's the trick? The bananas keep the brownies super moist while the pudding swirls add that creamy touch that hooks everyone.
Key Ingredients and Smart Shopping Advice
- Bananas - Go for ones with dark speckles for maximum sweetness. I've noticed that bananas you might think are too ripe for snacking work best in this recipe
- Vanilla Wafer Cookies - Make sure they're fresh and crunchy. The texture really matters in the final dessert. I usually grab an extra package since they tend to disappear while I'm baking
- Brown Sugar - Either light or dark works great, though dark adds more caramel notes. Pop a bread slice in the container to keep it soft
- Butter - Stick with unsalted so you can adjust the saltiness yourself. Let it sit out for smoother pudding
- Vanilla Extract - The real stuff makes a big difference in both the pudding and brownie parts
After many batches, I've learned that getting the right amount of mashed banana is super important - too much makes them cakey, too little and you'll miss that banana pudding magic.
Step-by-Step Baking Guide
- 1. Make Your Pudding
- First, get the vanilla pudding going - warm milk in a thick-bottomed pot over medium heat. In another bowl, mix sugar, flour, and egg yolk until light colored. Slowly pour the hot milk into this mix while constantly stirring - I learned the hard way that going too fast here can turn your eggs lumpy. Pour it all back into the pot and keep stirring until it's thick enough to coat your spoon, usually 5-7 minutes of non-stop stirring.
- 2. Mix Brownie Base
- While pudding cools down, start on your brownie mixture. Melt butter just until liquid - warm works better than hot. Stir with both sugars until blended. Now comes the fun part - add those perfectly ripened mashed bananas and watch your batter transform. Stir in egg yolk and vanilla until everything looks shiny and smooth.
- 3. Add Dry Stuff
- Sift flour, baking powder, and salt together - this step cuts out lumps and spreads everything evenly. Gently fold this into your wet mix, stopping as soon as you can't see flour anymore. Stirring too much ruins that fudgy texture we want.
- 4. Build Your Layers
- Now for the construction phase. Spread half the brownie mix in your pan - I use a spoon back to smooth it out. Push a layer of vanilla wafers into this batter, creating that classic banana pudding foundation.
- 5. Put It All Together
- Drop spoonfuls of your remaining brownie mix and cooled pudding in a checkerboard pattern. Make pretty swirls using a knife tip - I find that figure-eights create the prettiest marble effect.
Pin it
When I was testing this recipe, my little girl suggested we sprinkle crushed wafers on top before baking for extra crunch. She was totally right - turns out kids can give the best cooking advice!
Pin it
Mastering Oven Temperature
Getting your oven heat just right matters a ton here. I keep a thermometer inside my oven to make sure it's actually hitting 350°F. When you pull them out, the middle should still wobble slightly - it'll firm up as it cools down.
Getting That Perfect Consistency
The toothpick test works differently with these because of the pudding swirls. Look for slightly damp crumbs from brownie sections, while pudding areas will stay creamy.
Keeping Them Fresh
These actually taste even better the day after you make them, once all the flavors have mingled. Keep them in a sealed container at room temp for up to 3 days.
Pro Baker Tricks
- Always put parchment paper in your pan with extra hanging over the sides for easy lifting. Trying to scoop the first brownie from an unlined pan will break your heart
- Eggs mix in better when they're not cold from the fridge. I dunk mine in warm water for 5 minutes if I forget to set them out ahead of time
- Don't overdo the swirling - too much mixing blurs the nice contrast between pudding and brownie parts
Pin it
Closing Thoughts
These Banana Pudding Brownies give you the best of both treats - fudgy, rich brownies plus the homey comfort of banana pudding. They've become my favorite thing to bring to gatherings, not just because they taste amazing, but because they make everyone smile with that first bite. I learn something new each time I bake them, but the simple magic of combining these two desserts never fails to wow people.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Why is flour measurement important?
- Bad measuring creates dry brownies - grab a spoon-level tool or kitchen scale
- → Can I use boxed pudding instead?
- Homemade tastes best but you can try instant pudding if you're in a hurry
- → How should my bananas look?
- Go for super ripe bananas with brown spots for maximum flavor
- → Can I save these for later?
- You bet, they'll last up to 1 month when frozen in a sealed container
- → Why aren't my brownies soft and gooey?
- You probably added too much flour - be careful when measuring