Pin it
This giant muffaletta sandwich brings the iconic New Orleans classic right to your kitchen. The combination of savory Italian meats, cheese, and tangy olive salad pressed between a round loaf creates a showstopper that's perfect for feeding a crowd or meal prepping for busy days ahead.
I first made this muffaletta for a backyard picnic and was amazed at how the flavors developed while we played yard games. Now it's my go-to contribution for potlucks because it actually tastes better when made a few hours ahead.
Ingredients
- Green olives: bring briny saltiness that cuts through the rich meats
- Giardiniera: adds texture and tangy vegetable notes that brighten each bite
- Roasted red peppers: provide sweet smoky depth to balance the salty components
- Shallot: delivers a milder onion flavor that won't overpower other ingredients
- Capers: contribute bursts of briny goodness throughout the olive salad
- Garlic: infuses the olive salad with aromatic pungency
- Olive oil: use extra virgin for the best flavor profile in the olive spread
- Red wine vinegar: adds essential acidity to cut through the fatty meats and cheese
- Italian herbs: dried basil and oregano provide authentic Mediterranean flavor
- Large round Italian bread loaf: choose one with a sturdy crust to hold up to the fillings
- Cold cuts: select quality meats from the deli counter rather than pre-packaged for best flavor
- Provolone cheese: adds creamy mellowness to counter the bold olive salad
Step-by-Step Instructions
- Prepare the olive salad:
- Combine all chopped vegetables and seasonings in a bowl and stir thoroughly. This mixture benefits from time to develop flavors so make it first. The finer you chop the ingredients the better they'll meld together and stay on the sandwich. Allow at least 30 minutes but making it a day ahead results in even better flavor.
- Prepare the bread:
- Slice the Italian loaf horizontally with a serrated knife keeping the cut perfectly parallel. The ideal loaf has a sturdy exterior but a soft interior. If your bread is particularly doughy you can remove some of the interior crumb to create more space for fillings but be careful not to remove too much or the sandwich will lose structural integrity.
- Layer the fillings:
- Begin with a generous layer of olive salad on the bottom half of bread allowing the oil to soak into the bread somewhat. Follow with even layers of meats and cheese alternating them for the best texture and flavor distribution. The traditional order is turkey first followed by mortadella then salami and finally provolone on top before adding another layer of olive salad.
- Compress and rest:
- Place the top half of the bread firmly on the sandwich and wrap tightly with plastic wrap or foil. Place a heavy cutting board or cast iron skillet on top to press the sandwich gently. This crucial resting period allows flavors to meld and helps the sandwich hold together when sliced. At minimum rest for 30 minutes but 2 hours is ideal for perfect texture.
- Slice and serve:
- Use a very sharp serrated knife to cut the muffaletta into wedges like a pie. Clean your knife between cuts for the cleanest presentation. If serving for a crowd arrange the wedges on a platter with extra napkins as this sandwich can be deliciously messy.
When I visited New Orleans years ago I tried the original muffaletta at Central Grocery and became obsessed with recreating it at home. The olive salad is truly the star here. I make extra batches now to keep in the refrigerator for quick sandwiches or as a topping for grilled chicken.
Make-Ahead Options
The olive salad can be prepared up to three days in advance and stored in an airtight container in the refrigerator. This not only saves preparation time but actually improves the flavor as the ingredients have more time to marry together. The complete sandwich can be assembled up to 24 hours before serving. In fact many muffaletta enthusiasts insist that the sandwich reaches its peak flavor after sitting for several hours as the bread absorbs the olive oil and vinegar while the meats and cheeses meld their flavors.
Customization Ideas
While the traditional muffaletta follows a specific formula feel free to adjust the ingredients to suit your preferences. Vegetarians can replace the meats with additional layers of cheese grilled vegetables or even slices of firm tofu marinated in Italian dressing. For a spicier version add pepperoncini to the olive salad or layer in some spicy capicola or soppressata in place of the turkey. If you have family members who dislike olives you can separate portions of the sandwich with just a vinaigrette dressing instead of the olive salad.
Serving Suggestions
A muffaletta is substantial enough to be a complete meal but pairs beautifully with simple sides. Serve alongside kettle chips for crunch or a light green salad dressed with lemon and olive oil to balance the richness of the sandwich. For a true New Orleans experience accompany with Zapp's potato chips and an ice cold beer or Italian soda. If serving at a party cut into smaller wedges as appetizers rather than full meal portions since the sandwich is quite filling.
The Cultural Significance
The muffaletta sandwich originated in New Orleans at Central Grocery in 1906 when Sicilian immigrant Salvatore Lupo created it for the local workers. Named after the round Sicilian sesame bread traditionally used the sandwich became a staple of New Orleans cuisine and represents the significant influence of Sicilian immigrants on the city's food culture. Today it remains an iconic dish that bridges Italian and American culinary traditions and exemplifies how immigrant foods evolve in their new homes while maintaining connections to their origins.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → What bread is best for this sandwich?
A round Italian loaf, about 10 inches in diameter, works perfectly. Its sturdy texture holds up to the fillings and olive salad.
- → Can I make the olive salad ahead of time?
Yes, the olive salad can be prepared a day in advance. Store it in the refrigerator to allow the flavors to meld even more.
- → What if I don't have giardiniera?
You can substitute giardiniera with any pickled vegetables you have, such as pickled carrots, cauliflower, or pepperoncini.
- → How long should the sandwich rest before serving?
Allow the sandwich to rest for at least 30 minutes, wrapped tightly, at room temperature. This enhances the flavor and helps the fillings set.
- → Can I customize the meats and cheeses?
Absolutely! Swap out the turkey, mortadella, salami, or provolone for your favorite deli meats and cheeses.
- → What's a good side dish for this sandwich?
This hearty sandwich pairs well with a simple green salad, kettle chips, or even a bowl of soup.