Pin it
No-Fuss Chile Relleno Bake
Here's my take on a fuss-free version of chile rellenos that ditches the deep fryer but keeps all the tasty elements. By combining charred poblanos with gooey cheese and airy egg mixture, this straightforward dish turns out absolutely wonderful. I'm a fan of how it fits any mealtime, and the aroma of those roasted peppers fills my house with mouthwatering scents.
What Makes This Crowd-Pleasing Dish Special
This no-fuss bake stands out because:
- You won't need to mess with hot oil or batter
- The combo of smoky peppers and melted cheese tastes incredible
- It works for morning, midday, or evening meals
- You can tweak the recipe to match your preferences
Basic Components for Tasty Bake
- Poblano Peppers: Char them yourself for best flavor or grab canned ones when you're in a hurry.
- Cheeses: Freshly shredded Monterey Jack and cheddar create that perfect melty texture.
- Eggs: They form the soft, puffy base that brings everything together.
- Whole Milk: Adds a smooth, velvety quality to the egg mixture.
- Flour and Baking Powder: These give your casserole that lovely rise.
- Seasonings: Basic spices enhance the overall taste profile.
Quick Preparation Guide
- Char Your Peppers Perfectly
- Set poblanos under the broiler roughly 4 inches from the heat source. Let them cook for 5-7 minutes on each side, flipping now and then, until they're nicely blackened and bubbly all around. The outer skin should turn nearly black - that's what gives you that smoky taste. Tuck them into a paper bag to steam for 15 minutes, then carefully strip off the skin and take out the seeds. Skip rinsing or you'll lose all that great flavor.
- Stack Your Ingredients
- Begin with a slim coating of egg mixture at the bottom of your dish - just enough to cover it. Arrange your charred peppers in one layer, making sure they're dabbed dry. Cover generously with cheese, getting it into every little space. Do this once more, adding another complete layer of peppers and cheese. This double-stack method guarantees you'll taste both peppers and cheese in every forkful.
- Whip Up the Egg Base
- In a big bowl, beat your eggs till they're airy and bubbly - about 2 minutes by hand or 1 minute using a mixer. Slowly pour in your milk while constantly stirring to keep it lump-free. Sprinkle in your flour and seasonings carefully to prevent clumps - nobody wants to bite into flour pockets. Keep mixing until it's totally smooth, then gently pour this mixture over your layers, allowing it to sink between the gaps.
- Cook It Right
- Put your casserole into your already hot 350°F oven - place it on the center rack for balanced heating. Around 35 minutes in, start checking if it's done - the surface should be nicely browned, and a knife stuck in the middle should come out clean. The center should be firm but slightly wobbly. Let it sit for 10-15 minutes before cutting - this helps it firm up and makes serving cleaner.
Tricks for Best Results
- Go for Hand-Roasted: Charring poblanos yourself adds tons more flavor.
- Skip Pre-Shredded: Cheese you grate yourself melts way better than bagged versions.
- Don't Rush: Giving it time to cool means neater portions.
Pin it
Quick Pairing Suggestions
Take this tasty bake up a notch with:
- A spoonful of cool sour cream and chunky salsa on each portion
- A side of fluffy Mexican rice or crisp green salad
Smart Prep Options
- Save time by charring peppers or putting the whole dish together a day before
- Enjoy extra portions within 3 days from the fridge or freeze for longer storage
- Heat it back up in your oven or microwave when you're hungry again
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Can I use canned chiles?
Sure, grab 3-4 (7 oz) cans of whole green chiles.
- → Why use a plastic bag for peppers?
Trapping steam helps peel the skins off easier.
- → Can I prep it ahead?
Stop after roasting peppers, then add eggs before baking.
- → Why rest before slicing?
It sets better, making cutting cleaner.
- → Can I freeze it?
Not a good idea—freezing messes with the eggs' texture.
- → What pairs well with it?
Try it with some salsa, fresh cilantro, or a dollop of sour cream.